From Shrimp to Whale: The Fan Types Your Price Is Attracting
💬 Not sure how this fits your page? Ask the help group on Telegram
Here's a truth that stings a little, gorgeous: your price doesn't just decide how much fans pay. It decides which fans show up. Cheap pages fill up with window shoppers. Confident pages attract people who came to spend.
Let's map the whole ocean of fan types on OnlyFans, Fansly and MYM Fans, then look at what a real pricing test showed.
The fan spending scale
Based on monthly spending with one creator, here's the playful classification we use in coaching:
| Type | Monthly spend | What they're like |
|---|---|---|
| 🐳 Whale | $5,000+ | Rare, ultra-loyal, wants a truly personal experience |
| 💎 Premium | $1,000-$5,000 | Generous, buys customs and VIP offers |
| 🦈 Shark | $500-$1,000 | Regular, solid support, values attention |
| 🐬 Dolphin | $100-$500 | Consistent buyer, the backbone of a healthy page |
| 🐟 Fish | $50-$100 | Typical fan who buys now and then |
| 🐙 Octopus | $20-$50 | Small budget, still contributes regularly |
| 🦀 Crab | $10-$20 | Rarely buys extras |
| 🦐 Shrimp | $1-$10 | Minimal spending |
| 💤 Zero spender | $0 | Follows, looks, never buys |
These thresholds are a tool, not a law. What matters is the mix on your page.
What our pricing test showed
Our coach ran two MYM account setups at different price points to see which fans each attracted:
- Free account: a big follower count, mostly shrimp and zero spenders. Almost no revenue.
- $20 account: far fewer fans, but octopuses, fish and even a few dolphins. About twice the revenue with roughly ten times fewer fans.
One test, one creator, so not a universal rule. But it matches what we see again and again: a price filters your audience.
A thousand shrimp won't pay your rent. Ten dolphins might.
Why low prices attract low spenders
- Bargain hunters love bargains. A $3 or free page is a magnet for people who never intended to spend.
- Perceived value drops. A low price tells fans your content is ordinary. See the topaz trick.
- Your time gets eaten. Hundreds of low spenders send messages too, and answering them all leaves less time for your best fans.
Free pages can still work
A free page isn't automatically a mistake. It works when you have:
- a strong PPV system with clear tiers (the value ladder),
- time (or help) to chat with a lot of people,
- a clear path to move fans up from shrimp to fish and beyond.
Without that, a paid subscription is simpler and usually more profitable.
Get the free 30-Day Pricing Plan: a baseline week, two test weeks and a bundle week.
Join the creators group to get the plan
PDF pinned in the group. What is inside?
How to price for the fans you want
- Decide who you want: a few dolphins and sharks, or a big crowd of fish? Read whales vs sardines.
- Set your subscription to filter: a higher price keeps zero spenders out.
- Build a ladder so every type has a next step: teaser, set, premium video, custom.
- Track revenue per fan, not follower count.
- Give it 30 days before judging. Read your price is your positioning.
Treat every type with respect
Classifying fans helps you plan your time and offers, but they are people, not fish. Be kind to the shrimp (some become dolphins), never shame anyone's budget, and never push a fan past what he can afford. For moving fans up gently, read how to maximize a fan's spending.
FAQ
What are the different types of OnlyFans fans?
A common playful scale goes from zero spenders and shrimp ($1-10/month) up to fish, dolphins, sharks, premium fans and whales ($5,000+/month with one creator).
Do free OnlyFans pages attract worse fans?
Free pages often attract many low or zero spenders. They can still work with a strong PPV system and enough time to chat, but they're harder to make profitable.
Will raising my price attract better fans?
Often, yes. A higher subscription price filters out people who never planned to spend and signals premium value to those who do.
What did the free vs $20 test show?
In our coach's MYM test, the $20 account made about twice the revenue with roughly ten times fewer fans than the free account. It's one test, not a universal rule.
How do I know my fan mix?
Use your platform's stats to list top spenders and group fans by monthly spending. Track revenue per fan over time.
Should I ignore low-spending fans?
No. Be kind and give them a next step. Just don't let them take all your time away from your most engaged fans.
Bottom line
Your price is a fishing net. Choose the mesh on purpose, build a ladder for every fan who swims in, and watch your page get calmer and richer at the same time. 🐬